Tuesday, March 30, 2010

The Sound of Dancing

In an earlier post on the geography of dancing (that is, the physical spaces in which Schubert improvised/played dance music) I wrote the following:
The distinct timbres of the three main registers on contemporary pianofortes would be audible nearby, less so on the dance floor, where the swishing of clothes and muffled swish-slide of light cloth dancing shoes would mingle with the music.
Since writing that sentence, I have been wondering about those shoes. I wrote "light cloth dancing shoes" (that is to say, shoes of a fabric, shape, and weight similar to modern ballet slippers) because those are recognized as the standard from historical sources (dance instruction manuals and iconography). Here is a close-up from the rightmost couple in my logo graphic. This comes from 1808 and so can reasonably be regarded as typical at least into the early 1820s, and the dancers are dressed in a way that corresponds to the social class of Schubert and his friends.

A dance party (house ball) was not like a Clara Schumann recital -- strictly ordered, staid, and quiet. And since one of the few predictable elements would have been the alternation between dancing and eating/drinking, one has to ask whether the participants changed their shoes from one to the other. Given the protocols for dress, it would seem uncouth (or else youthfully rebellious) to wear dancing slippers while eating and talking. If Schubert's friends took the time to change their shoes, that action would would have affected the timing and process of the dancing and therefore also of Schubert's playing: it would necessarily articulate or "formalize" the dancing -- setting a particular dance segment off, as when a modern dance band takes a break. For Schubert, the inclination to group his waltzes by some (any) sort of connecting logic would have increased at least as much as with the "endless cotillions." In fact, perhaps more so, as he would have had more opportunity to organize distinct, small sets in the dance-trio(s) mould.

Monday, March 29, 2010

mediant blocking in D145n7

A simple diatonic mediant move (effecting the transformation R twice) is aligned with formal design in an early ternary waltz that also happens to contrast Ländler and deutscher traits (the former in the main theme, the latter in the contrasting middle) using sharp dynamic contrast to make the point unmistakably. In the example below, the mediant moves are outlined. (Another reminder that the graphics are thumbnails -- click on them to see the original-size file.)


Perhaps because of the change of figuration assisting the topic change, the left hand does not execute the transformations directly (in the manner of the Riemannian Hand). Instead, the right hand works out a pattern that combines transformation with registral shifts.

In mm. 3-4, the Hand would seem to be as at "a?": Bb4-Eb5-G5, but the direct move is from the shape at "a". The "b?" to which "a" moves is not literal, however (there is no Eb5); instead, the Eb is shifted upward to Eb6 (as at "b"). In the reprise this shape settles down as C5 goes to Bb4 (at "c?"), but the final move again takes the lowest note up an octave: G5 to G6 at "c."

Thursday, March 18, 2010

16-bar sentences; more to D810

Yesterday's post dealt with the expansion of D790n6 into the scherzo of the "Death and the Maiden" Quartet. For the trio, I'll do the reverse: pull out of the existing piece a plausible dance source. Actually, it's quite easy to do because the trio is set up as strain + varied repetition, and the contrasting middle is cleanly segregated out.


The 16-bar strain is by no means common in the waltzes, and most of those are periods (which, it must be said, are just as easily understood as written-out repetition with a varied cadence). Of 16-bar sentences, there are only seven, and all but one is early. The list is D128n10; D145ns 1, 3 12; D146ns 5, 6; and D969n5; they appear in a gallery below, with the articulation at eight bars marked in red. (D145n3 is an exception: the red line marks the "proper" end of the 16 strain, before the second 8 are repeated.)








Wednesday, March 17, 2010

A Deutscher in D810

In his review of Christopher Gibbs' biography, Brian Newbould mentions Schubert's use of a Deutscher, D790n6, as the basis for the scherzo in D810 (the "Death and the Maiden" Quartet). Here they are, the latter in Salomon Jadassohn's piano reduction. The opening motive is boxed in red, the more extended citation of the melody in purple, then a two-bar block quoted directly but without the eighth notes (again in purple), and finally the eight-bar direct quote that opens the contrasting middle (in green).



The blocking out of the material is convincing -- the dance's opening figure obviously makes a distinctive germ motive, but the harmonic instability of the first phrase is much better suited to the continuation in a 16-bar sentence; the second phrase with its vii°7-i pair lends itself very well to sequences; and of course contrasting middles are easily movable. Schubert also duplicates and expands on the affective contrast: waltzes often make a point of contrast in figuration, dynamics, and dance-style between individual phrases, not just between strains. As one particularly clear example that uses all three elements of contrast, see the opening of D779n16 below.

[added 5-19-10: David Brodbeck goes through the scherzo of D810, noting that the connection to D790n6 was originally raised by Maurice Brown (Brodbeck, 32-34).]

References.
Newbould, Brian. Review of Christopher Gibbs, The Life of Schubert. Notes 58/1(2001): 82-83.
Brodbeck, David. "Dance Music as High Art: Schubert's Twelve Ländler, op. 171 (D. 790)." In Walter Frisch, ed. Schubert: Critical and Analytical Studies, 31-47. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press, 1986.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Mailer's Strauss

I interrupt the hommage series for a book review. Franz Mailer's annotated works-catalogue for Johann Strauss, jr., is a delightful find. It reminds me very much of the dedicated, knowledgeable fan literature that is at least as important to film studies as anything written by academic scholars. There's very little room left for such writing in concert music studies. Granted, as in most fan literature, Strauss can do no wrong, but one knows the attitude going in and, as in the best of the fan literature, Mailer's catalogue wraps a great deal of interesting information around his advocacy.

The foreword is a short pair of paragraphs, then follows a 360-page alphabetized list of Strauss's compositions, each of which receives at least a third to a half page of commentary (and, commendably, without bias toward the well-known pieces: The Blue Danube is given no more space than the Künstler-Quadrille, op. 201). The last 15 pages is another works list, this time by opus number and with place and date of the premiere. The usual stragglers (pieces without opus numbers, etc.) are given a separate spot at the end.

Mailer's writing is very clear, without the Viennese colloquialisms he might have been tempted to bring in, and he consistently offers context (historical, geographical, political, and biographical -- though by no means always in that order). There is little here that cannot be found in other books on Strauss and the Strauss family, but it is particularly appealing to find the focus squarely on the compositions. I can imagine writers of CD liner notes mining this book for many years to come.

Performance of the music is, understandably, given priority over the immediate social contexts of that performance, though one does learn a number of details of venues. And occasionally one gets a hint of dancing, as in the account of Die jungen Wiener, op. 7, a waltz set featured in a Carneval-ball on 22 January 1845. According to Mailer, Strauss used the contrast between a dramatic introduction and the first waltz's "rocking, caressing melody" as a device "to entice [his audience of] young Viennese onto the dance floor of the elegant Dommayer Casino" (170-71). A review of another ball two weeks later notes approvingly the 19-year-old's "playful, piquant, and dance-inviting [tanzauffordernden] melodies" (99) -- this in the commentary on Faschings-Lieder-Walzer, op. 11.

Schubert was 19 barely thirty years earlier. He would have been 48 when Strauss's op. 11 was first performed; his children might have attended the ball in the Sträußelsälen (Theater in der Josefstadt).

Link to a Johann Strauss website, which includes here a charmingly indignant retort to the many writers who have assumed that the composer began with 12-15 players; his first orchestra was 24 players. Because of their contracts, they would also have played at the two balls mentioned above.

Update 6-3-10: Apparently, Mailer is more than a fan: in the traditional philologically oriented manner of the Germanophone musicologist, he has spent 25 years writing a biography of Johann Strauss, jr., a work that has expanded into ten volumes: Grösste Strauss-Biographie aller Zeiten.

Reference.
Mailer, Franz. Johann Strauss: Kommentiertes Werkverzeichnis. Wien: Pichler, 1999.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Schubert's personal soundscape

By "personal soundscape" I mean the ambient sound and resonance of his room(s). In this post, however, I am actually focusing on musical instruments again, as I am still vexed over Robert Winter's statement about pianos, repeated below from this post.
. . . the truly remarkable fact that Schubert did not have regular access to a piano as he composed. Robert Winter, in the New Grove biographical sketch of Schubert, writes that in late 1824,"Schubert moved briefly . . . for one last time into the Schubert family home. . . . It was the only place he ever lived in that contained a piano; Schubert never bought, leased or borrowed a piano of his own."
Schubert writes his siblings in October 1818: "Do take my fortepiano; I shall be delighted" (Deutsch 109). The instrument is presumably the Graf said to have been given Schubert by his father in 1814 (44). Schwind's drawing of Schubert's room with a piano was made in 1821 (163; 204; also my earlier post). In notes on Schubert's estate expenses, Deutsch says that "Schubert no longer owned a pianoforte, but had used that in Schober's lodgings" (849). Johann Mayrhofer's recollections of sharing a room with Schubert in 1819 include the remark that, ten years later (that is in 1829), the room still held "a played-out pianoforte" (860); in the notes a further quote to this: "Schubert had a miserable pianoforte standing in a narrow room" (864).

Dieckmann's comments on Wilhelm Rieder's formal portrait of Schubert, an oil painting done decades after the composer's death, suggest that Winter took too literally another late-life recollection: Schubert's lively but problematic friend Joseph von Spaun claimed that the composer never owned and didn't use a piano to compose (Dieckmann, 102). Dieckmann thinks that the piano drawn by Schwind in 1821 is the same instrument given Franz several years earlier by his father; it would have gone along when Schubert moved back into the family home in fall 1822 and was probably left there the following year as he went back and forth between the house and the city. From early 1825, he may not have had an instrument but played those in friends' houses nearby (Dieckmann 106-7).

The end result: Winter is apparently wrong; Schubert did own a piano and had it with him in his rooms at least part of the time up to 1825; he may very well have composed without an instrument; no one mentions a violin.

References.
Dieckmann, Friedrich. Franz Schubert: eine Annäherung. Frankfurt am Main: Insel Verlag, 1996.
Deutsch, Otto. Eric Blom, trans. Schubert: A Documentary Biography. London: J. M. Dent, 1946.