Sunday, February 28, 2010

D924 and dancing

The last two blog entries, which contrasted traditional Urlinie readings with those based on an Ursatz manqué, made an assumption that is typical of these modes of analysis but is questionable, especially for waltzes (or other small-scale pieces, such as songs). Far from being the staid forms that tie the chaos of the foreground to the eternal, these backgrounds are highly contingent -- fragile and easily disrupted. We've met some of the devices before: the stability of its tonal "reference point" -- whether upper voice or bass -- is quickly undermined if it is played as trio to another dance, or enhanced if it is given a trio and a subsequent da capo.

In the double-tonic numbers of D924 there is even another possibility -- that the strains themselves were detached from their companions and played in differing combinations. This is of course speculative -- an extension "backwards" to Schubert's improvisation practice -- but one does find such "floating strains" in Schumann's Papillons, for example, and the topically uniform character of most of D924 makes its both easier and more plausible as well.

I have assembled below a dance-sequence that uses the first strain of n3 as the refrain. More repetition or extension would probably be necessary, but even in this form up to three minutes of dancing would be available. The sequence is n3, a, b, a -- n2, all -- n3, a -- n5, all -- n3, a -- n4, all. The key sequence is c#, E, c# - E - c# - A - c# - A.


Saturday, February 27, 2010

D924 and tonality in sets, part 2

This continues yesterday's post on certain numbers in the Gräzer Walzer, D924. Five dances (n3, 6, 7, 9, 11) have minor-key first strains that then modulate in the second strain to the relative major key, all but one ending there and thus creating double-tonic constructions. Here I will look at n6 & n9.

It's much harder to hear n6 in the same way (as n3--see yesterday's post) because C#6, which will become A:^3 in the second strain (circled), is too obviously a cover tone here and lines too obviously move from A5 (see the several circled notes and the added/implied G#5 in red). The second strain is less sharply profiled -- in a word, ambiguous -- but it would seem that A:^3 has priority -- follow circled and added notes -- while covering activity (boundary play) actually gets more attention (boxed notes). The background understood traditionally is not a problem: both A5 and F#3 are middleground prefixes to C#6 and A3, respectively. With more sensitivity to its expressive qualities, the waltz's Ursatz is again non-traditional, and its Urlinie, too: A5-C#6-B5-A5.


The last example is n9, which goes still further, as a reading with a traditional descending line requires a clumsy transgression of the voice leading in the first strain ("crossing" the soprano and alto voices in mm. 7-8 (boxed)). In the second strain, C:^5 is easily read as descending (F5 in m.10, E5 in m.11, D5-C5 in the final bars) but just as easily -- and more effectively -- as rising from ^5 steadily upward to ^8 (the line is boxed).

Friday, February 26, 2010

D924 and tonality in sets

The Gräzer Walzer, with the Valses nobles, represent the late style among Schubert's dances, as they were most likely composed/written down in 1826 or 1827. Of the two sets, the Valses nobles, with their often elongated and asymmetrical forms and leaning toward distinctly pianistic textures and gestures, show much more tension between playing for dancing and playing for listening. The Gräzer Walzer, with the possible exception of the last one (n12), which might have been conceived as the typically extended coda of the set, are all entirely danceable and may in fact easily be strung together to create extended sequences. Many, in fact, have very distinct Ländler characteristics, which seems a bit surprising for such a late period in Schubert's life.

A curiosity of D924 is the large number of minor-key first strains (5), all of which modulate in the second strain to the relative major key. These are n3: c#-E; n6: f#-A; n7: a-C (1st ending), a (second ending); n9: a-C; n11:e-G. All five end in the major key, except for n7, as shown.

In traditional Schenkerian analysis, priority goes to the end, and therefore all but n7 would be read in terms of the ending key, with the opening key situated in the middleground. I'll adopt that view here for sake of discussion, but in general it strikes me that this sort of bald hierarchization misses much of the expressive point of these pieces: their strains and their keys are balanced, two pictures in a locket -- and family pictures at that, as Schubert follows his earlier habit (exemplified in a skewed way in D779n13) of transposing the first strain to serve (with minor emendations) as the second. It seems to me that David Lewin's conception of key change (allied to the double-tonic complex but explicitly transformational) is a much better model.

In D924n3, Schubert plays a simple polyphonic game, flipping the priorities of uppermost and "alto" voice in the right hand. The G#5 (boxed) may sound like a cover tone to ^3 (E5) at first, but the dogged and direct cadence carries the voice leading down from its ^5, not from E. In the second strain the weight is reversed (though of course we have no way of knowing that till the cadence arrives -- but that's often the expressive trajectory of Schubert's waltz strains): B5 does retreat to the cover tone role and the cadence ultimately moves down the G#5 of m. 9 past an incomplete NN (not boxed) A5 through F#5 to E5. Thus the Urlinie design converts c#:^5 to E: ^3, and the c# region becomes a middleground prefix in the bass -- unless you decide that's a bad idea and give the C# bass note the background status it deserves in a double-tonic complex.
I will look at two additional dances, n6 and n9, in tomorrow's post. Both show more extended versions of the same patterns.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

more to ^6 and the ninth

Today's entry [update] was originally a link to another web essay of mine, first posted in 2005, edited and reposted in 2008. The material from that essay has since been incorporated into an essay pulbished on the Texas Scholars Works platform: Nineteenth-century polkas with rising melodic and cadence gestures:  ^6 and V9 in early polkas. The waltz hinted broadly at reshaping practice with respect to ^6 and the upper tetrachord; the polka realized and naturalized it.

"Common practice" is a chimera, a vast and convenient reduction that has seen its chronologically early third chopped off by partimento studies and its later half chopped off by the waltz, the polka, and the symmetries uncovered by neo-Riemannian studies. What's left? Music for the bourgeoisie (that's the educated middle class) in barely two generations covering roughly the period 1780-1830 (with possible extension to 1850, in the "mannerist bourgeois" of Mendelssohn, Schumann, and A. B. Marx). This is the period of the turn from patronage to entrepeneurship. . . . See how easy it is to fall back into comfortable narratives? It was the period of the turn from patronage to entrepeneurship in Vienna -- a shift that had been accomplished in the wealthy, trade-oriented commercial cultures of England, Scotland, the Netherlands, and a few other countries starting already in the 17th century.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

More to recomposition

This is a continuation of yesterday's post. I have constructed a second re-composition that goes a rather different direction: where my chain of dances from D365 + D779n13 yesterday emphasized the Ländler traits of the group, here I will be fitting D779n13 (as a trio) to two numbers from the D783 German dances. The most boisterous of the lot, n1, starts, with D779n13 in its 16-bar version as a first trio; after a reprise of n1, the mode change ties the second trio to D779n13 as "other"; again reprise to close. This version simultaneously brings out the deutscher traits and the Zärtlichkeit of D779n13.


Another way to go about it brings tonal relations, including mediants, into strong relief. The initial dance-trio-dance-trio group is the same, but the second reprise of n1 is replaced by n9, a piece of similar character and in a mediant relation to n10, which precedes n9 here; another mediant change brings back the D779n13 trio, and finally we hear a reprise of n1 to round things off. Or: n1-13-1-10-9-13-1, and IDENT-IDENT-P-L-RP-IDENT, where IDENT means neither tonic nor mode change.


Monday, February 22, 2010

More to recomposition

Today's post is a reaction to Matthew Bailey-Shea's article on recomposition in Music Theory Online. He takes several settings of a poem by Goethe and performs a "mash up," generating a self-styled "musical Frankenstein" (para. 22) that you can both see and hear (there is an audio file). His argument is quite similar to Agawu's in promoting (re)composition-as-analysis, but Bailey-Shea is bolder in speaking to the value (not just utility) of the results.
. . . although there are a variety of goals for music analysis, one of the most common is to suggest new ways to hear a given piece. Such analyses succeed, moreover, when the proposed ways of hearing challenge us in a creative, insightful, and thought-provoking manner. And though intertextual analyses often succeed through simple verbal description there are good reasons to literally compose the proposed connections. We actually hear how these songs resonate with one another, comment upon and affect one another, reach out and engage other settings of the poem. The spark of intertextual association becomes far brighter and, in a way, the music speaks for itself. The analysis informs the music; the music is an analysis. (para. 7)
The resonance with my own posts (locate them with the label "recomposition") is obvious. My task is much simpler than merging elements from several setting into a single performable song, since the individual pieces remain distinct in a dance chain or even a suite for performance. Still, as he puts it, "Every manipulation, every distortion [was] designed to enhance our experience of these songs, both as individual compositions and as a group" (para. 22), and the same is true of any gathering of dances in a sequence: they cast light on each other, as it were.

Here is an example. I have taken three A major waltzes from D365 and added D779n13 to them, in its 16-bar version. The six dances are to be played in order, the idea being that the alternate dances are placed in relation to one another by the dance & (multiple) trio principle. So, the similar first strains of n17 and n28 are shown together, but the topical underpinnings of their markedly different second strains ("foot-stamping" in the first, "yodeling" in the second) are brought into relief. Likewise the "trios": leading-tone basses and initial dissonances of n30, n16, and -- after a restatement of the "dance" (n28 again rather than the original n17) -- D779n13.


Tomorrow's post will show two other re-compositions of a similar kind, utilizing dances from D783.